Hoka Challenger 5 ATR

Review Score
Your rating
Price band
Special versions

Pro athlete users

Cesar PicininJulien SimonHarry Jones
Newer model:

Buy Hoka Challenger 5 ATR at today's best price (men's/women's)

UK

Hoka Challenger 5 ATR: Review

“A versatile trail running shoe with excellent cushioning and traction.”

Overview


The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is a trail running shoe designed to handle a variety of terrains. This shoe is known for its versatility and comfort, making it a popular choice among trail runners.

Key Features:

  • Lightweight EVA Foam: Provides excellent cushioning without adding extra weight.
  • Sticky Rubber Outsole: Offers improved traction on rocky and loose terrain.
  • Dual-Layered Mesh Upper: Enhances breathability and sheds water efficiently.

The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is an ideal choice for runners who prioritize comfort and versatility for trail running. Its lightweight design and improved traction make it suitable for both road and trail use.

With an average review score of 69%, it's in the lowest rated 10% of similar running shoes. Based on our monitoring of prices across the internet, it's currently in the cheapest 20% of running shoes today.

Verdict

The consensus on the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR


The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is a versatile trail running shoe that performs well on a variety of surfaces. Reviewers appreciate its lightweight EVA foam cushioning, which provides comfort without adding bulk. The sticky rubber outsole offers improved traction, making it suitable for rocky and loose terrain. The dual-layered mesh upper enhances breathability and sheds water efficiently, making it a good choice for wet conditions. However, some users found the forefoot to be narrow and the heel to be wide, which may affect stability on uneven terrain. Overall, the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is a solid choice for trail runners looking for a comfortable and versatile shoe. Its combination of cushioning, traction, and breathability makes it a reliable option for various trail conditions.

Updates to Hoka Challenger 5 ATR


The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR features several updates from its predecessor, the Hoka Challenger 4 ATR. The most notable change is the addition of a sticky rubber outsole with larger, more durable lugs for improved traction. The dual-layered mesh upper has been redesigned to enhance breathability and water-shedding capabilities. The midsole now features firmer EVA foam, providing a more stable and responsive ride. These updates aim to improve the shoe's overall performance and comfort on various terrains.

Comparable Shoes


The Salomon Speedcross 5 is a good alternative for runners seeking a shoe with deeper lugs for better traction in muddy conditions. While the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR offers excellent cushioning and versatility, the Speedcross 5 excels in providing grip and stability on technical trails. However, the Speedcross 5 may not be as comfortable for long-distance runs due to its firmer midsole.

The Altra Lone Peak 4.5 is a zero-drop trail running shoe that offers a different running experience compared to the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR. The Lone Peak 4.5 features a wider toe box and a more flexible design, providing a natural foot movement. However, the Challenger 5 ATR offers better cushioning and a more responsive ride, making it suitable for long-distance runs.

Special versions of Hoka Challenger 5 ATR




The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR GTX is a special version of the Challenger 5 ATR, featuring a waterproof Gore-Tex membrane. This addition makes the shoe suitable for wet and muddy conditions, providing extra protection against water and moisture. The GTX version retains the same lightweight EVA foam midsole and sticky rubber outsole, ensuring excellent cushioning and traction. The dual-layered mesh upper is replaced with a waterproof material, maintaining breathability while keeping the feet dry.

10 Hoka Challenger 5 ATR Pros & Cons


5 Pros

Lightweight EVA foam provides excellent cushioning.
Sticky rubber outsole offers improved traction on rocky and loose terrain.
Dual-layered mesh upper enhances breathability and sheds water efficiently.
Available in both standard (D) and wide (EE) widths.
Versatile design suitable for both trail and road running.

5 Cons

Narrow forefoot and wide heel may cause foot shifting on uneven terrain.
Not suitable for extremely technical or muddy trails.
Maximalist cushioning may feel dissociative for some runners.
Outsole may wear down faster on pavement.
Slightly heavier than previous versions.

In Depth


Upper

The upper of the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR features a dual-layered mesh material that enhances breathability and sheds water efficiently. This design helps keep the feet dry and comfortable during runs, especially in wet conditions. The upper also includes a TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) covered toe bumper, which provides additional protection against rocks and roots. The mesh material is strong and durable, ensuring that the shoe can withstand the rigors of trail running.

Midsole

The midsole of the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is made from lightweight EVA foam, which offers excellent cushioning and shock absorption. This foam helps to reduce the impact on the feet and legs, making it ideal for long-distance runs. The midsole also provides a stable and responsive ride, allowing runners to maintain their pace and comfort over various terrains. The 5 mm heel-to-toe drop ensures a natural running motion, which can help reduce the risk of injury.

Outsole

The outsole of the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR features a sticky rubber compound with 4 mm deep rectangular lugs. This design provides improved traction on rocky and loose terrain, making it suitable for a variety of trail conditions. The lugs are strategically placed to offer better grip and durability, while the exposed EVA midsole foam helps to accentuate the lugs' effectiveness. The outsole's pattern is designed to perform well on both trails and roads, making the shoe a versatile option for runners.

Size/fit

The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is available in both standard (D) and wide (EE) widths, catering to a variety of foot shapes. However, some reviewers noted that the forefoot is narrow while the heel is wide, which may cause some foot shifting on uneven terrain. The shoe is true to size, and the redesigned lacing system helps to secure the foot in place. The collar and tongue are padded for added comfort, ensuring a snug fit during long runs.

Comfort

Comfort is a standout feature of the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR. The lightweight EVA foam midsole provides excellent cushioning, reducing the impact on the feet and legs. The dual-layered mesh upper enhances breathability, keeping the feet cool and dry. The shoe's design ensures a comfortable fit, with padding around the collar and tongue for added support. The Challenger 5 ATR is suitable for long-distance runs, as it helps to minimize fatigue and discomfort.

Cushioning

The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR offers exceptional cushioning, thanks to its lightweight EVA foam midsole. This foam provides a soft and responsive ride, absorbing the impact of each step and reducing the strain on the feet and legs. The cushioning is particularly beneficial for long-distance runs, as it helps to minimize fatigue and discomfort. The 5 mm heel-to-toe drop ensures a natural running motion, further enhancing the shoe's overall comfort.

Breathability

The dual-layered mesh upper of the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR enhances breathability, allowing air to circulate and keep the feet cool and dry. This design is particularly beneficial for long runs in warm conditions, as it helps to prevent overheating and discomfort. The mesh material also sheds water efficiently, making the shoe suitable for wet conditions. Overall, the breathability of the Challenger 5 ATR contributes to its overall comfort and performance.

Stability

Stability is a mixed aspect of the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR. While the lightweight EVA foam midsole provides a stable and responsive ride, some reviewers noted that the forefoot is narrow and the heel is wide, which may cause foot shifting on uneven terrain. The shoe's design includes a TPU covered toe bumper and a dual-layered mesh upper, which help to secure the foot in place. However, the stability may not be sufficient for runners who require additional support on technical trails.

Durability

The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is designed to withstand the rigors of trail running, with a durable dual-layered mesh upper and a sticky rubber outsole. The TPU covered toe bumper provides additional protection against rocks and roots, while the EVA foam midsole offers long-lasting cushioning. Some reviewers noted that the shoe's durability is comparable to other trail running shoes, making it a reliable option for long-distance runs. However, the outsole may wear down faster on pavement, so it is best suited for trail use.

Grip

The sticky rubber outsole of the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR features 4 mm deep rectangular lugs, providing excellent grip on rocky and loose terrain. The lugs are strategically placed to offer better traction and durability, making the shoe suitable for a variety of trail conditions. The outsole's pattern is designed to perform well on both trails and roads, making the Challenger 5 ATR a versatile option for runners. However, the grip may not be sufficient for extremely technical or muddy trails.

Flex

The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR offers a good balance of flexibility and support, thanks to its lightweight EVA foam midsole and dual-layered mesh upper. The shoe's design allows for natural foot movement, while still providing the necessary support for trail running. The 5 mm heel-to-toe drop ensures a smooth and natural running motion, further enhancing the shoe's overall flexibility. The Challenger 5 ATR is suitable for a variety of trail conditions, offering a comfortable and responsive ride.

Who should buy the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR?


The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is ideal for trail runners who seek a versatile and comfortable shoe for various terrains. Runners who appreciate maximalist cushioning will find the lightweight EVA foam midsole beneficial for long-distance runs. Those who run in wet conditions will appreciate the shoe's breathable and water-shedding dual-layered mesh upper. Additionally, runners with high arches will find the shoe's design supportive and comfortable.

Who should not buy the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR?


The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR may not be suitable for runners who require a highly stable shoe for technical trails. The narrow forefoot and wide heel may cause foot shifting on uneven terrain, which could be problematic for those needing extra support. Runners who prefer a more sensitive shoe with better trail feel might find the maximalist cushioning too dissociative. For those seeking a shoe with deeper lugs for muddy conditions, other options may be more appropriate.

Hoka Challenger 5 ATR: What's it good for?


The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is good for a variety of running and exercise activities. It excels in trail running on dry and moderately technical terrains. The shoe's breathable upper and water-shedding capabilities make it suitable for wet conditions. Its maximalist cushioning is ideal for long-distance runs, providing comfort and reducing fatigue. The versatile design also allows for occasional road running, making it a great all-around option for runners.

5 Hoka Challenger 5 ATR FAQs


Is the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR suitable for road running?

Yes, the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is versatile enough to be used for road running. Its lightweight EVA foam midsole provides excellent cushioning, and the sticky rubber outsole offers good traction on both trails and roads.

Does the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR come in different widths?

Yes, the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is available in both standard (D) and wide (EE) widths, catering to a variety of foot shapes. This ensures a comfortable fit for runners with different foot widths.

How does the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR perform in wet conditions?

The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR performs well in wet conditions, thanks to its dual-layered mesh upper that enhances breathability and sheds water efficiently. The sticky rubber outsole provides good traction on wet surfaces.

Is the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR suitable for long-distance runs?

Yes, the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR is suitable for long-distance runs. Its lightweight EVA foam midsole provides excellent cushioning and reduces fatigue, making it a comfortable option for extended runs.

What is the heel-to-toe drop of the Hoka Challenger 5 ATR?

The Hoka Challenger 5 ATR has a heel-to-toe drop of 5 mm, which ensures a natural running motion and helps reduce the risk of injury.

Hoka Challenger 5 ATR alternatives



Hoka Challenger 5 ATR
Now viewing

Hoka Challenger 5 ATR
bestDealShow prices
priceBand
Price band
released
Released
Jan 2019
May 2019Jul 2019Mar 2018Mar 2018
expertReviewScore
Expert Review Score












productAthletes
Pro athlete users

+3
Julien SimonHarry Jones

Jeffrey SternPablo Villalobos

+5
Elov OlssonRyan Woods

Jesse ShotlandDamian Hall
Weight
Weight
M: 266 g
W: 218 g
M: 181 g
W: 142 g
M: 241 g
W: 190 g
215 g
M: 204 g
W: 170 g
235 g
Forefoot
Forefoot
26 mm
5 mm
17 mm
16 mm
M: 18 mm
W: 16 mm
7 mm
Heel to toe drop
Heel to toe drop
5 mm
4 mm
3 mm
4 mm
Heel
Heel
31 mm
5 mm
17 mm
20 mm
M: 21 mm
W: 19 mm
11 mm
Terrain
Terrain
Trail
TrailTrailTrailMudTrailTrail
Brand
Brand
Hoka
VibramMerrellSalomonHokaInov-8
Shoe Type
Shoe Type
Maximalist
BarefootLightweightLow dropMinimalistZero dropLightweightLow dropZero dropLightweightLow dropLightweightLow dropLightweightLow drop
Techs
Techs
Vibram
Waterproofings
Waterproofings
Water repellent
Environmental Characteristics
Environmental Characteristics
Vegan Ⓥ
Vegan Ⓥ
Vegan ⓋVegan Ⓥ
0

Hoka Challenger 5 ATR: what the experts say (3 reviews)

Hoka Challenger 5 ATR: 2 Expert video reviews

Hoka Challenger 5 ATR: 1 Manufacturer video

Hoka Challenger 5 ATR characteristics and specifications

Characteristics
SportsRunning (+2048)
TerrainTrail (+533)
BrandHoka (+107)
Support TypeNeutral (+1602)
Pronation TypeNeutral pronation (+1577)
Strike TypeFore/Midfoot strike (+1113)
Arch TypeHigh arch (+1524)
Shoe TypeMaximalist (+428)
FitMedium toe box (+853)
Events10k (+711)Half marathon (+711)Marathon (+711)
Environmental CharacteristicsVegan Ⓥ (+250)
ColorwaysAbep, Anthracite / Antigua Sand, Blue / Grey, Blue / Orange, Blue / Red, Bspb, Charcoal Gray / Fusion Coral, Dbcb, Ebony / Black, Frost Gray / Bright Marigold
Specificationsvs Average
Model
5 ATR
Released
Jan 2019
Measurements
Weight
M: 266 g
W: 218 g
Heel to toe drop
5 mm
Heel
31 mm
Forefoot
26 mm

5 pro athletes who've used Hoka Challenger 5 ATR

Related guides

AuthorTom Green
Tom is the founder of geerly. Based in West London, he found his passion for running in his mid-30s. He’s best at longer distances, and is a regular at the London Marathon, where he's edging closer to sub-2.40. He started geerly because he found it frustrating when shopping for running shoes spending ages trying to find the best deal in his size, and wading through verbose, waffling reviews clearly designed to appeal to search engines rather than be helpful to users. For geerly he's passionate about writing reviews that get straight to the point, and helping runners find the right gear at the best price.
new!
Sync your parkrun results to your Strava activities
Profile picture
Tom Green
October 17, 2024 at 9:55 AM
Gunnersbury parkrun #230 (my #3️⃣4️⃣)
📊 Stats by geerly 👟 🕒 Official time: 00:22:45 | Course PB 🚨 🏁 Overall position: 35/549 🚹 Gender position: 21/299 🎯 Age grade: 61%